Reseña de I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde.
I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. de Oceania Resumen del Libro
Until Les Hiatt published his critical assessment of Radcliffe-Brown's classic 1930-1 formulation of Australian territorial organization in 1962, the model had remained virtually unchallenged. (1) It is true that W.E.H. Stanner (1933) in the Daly River area, Lauriston Sharp (1934) and Donald Thomson (1939: 211-12) working in Cape York, and Phyllis Kaberry (1939:30-1, 136) and Theodore Hernandez (1941) working in the Kimberley, had all indicated that some aspect of the model did not apply to groups of bush dwelling Aboriginal people they worked with, prior to 1962, but it was only with Hiatt's critique that the evidence was marshalled, and a compelling and coherent case made for the incoherence of Radcliffe-Brown's formulation of the concept of the horde. (2) In the terminology of today, the horde is referred to as the band or land-using group, as opposed to the clan or land-owning group. Although Radcliffe-Brown tried to maintain this distinction, he used the term horde inconsistently, sometimes for the land-using and sometimes for the land-owning group, and asserted that the land-using group was made up of males only from the landowning group (clan). (3) Hiatt clearly demonstrated the falsity of this assertion by showing that no such land-using group had been reported in the Australian literature. Outside native title applications and land claims, and ethnographic reconstruction, this debate is only of historical importance today, but in the middle 1960s it was heated and significant. If Hiatt was correct, it meant the elegant and aesthetically appealing fit between Aboriginal social and local organization, was disrupted. The purest expression of this fit was Claude Levi-Strauss's (1949) model of Aboriginal society, in which the males of each patrilineal clan lived on their own clan's estate and were linked to surrounding clans by the exchange of sisters. Hiatt compounded his 1962 attack on this orderly system at the Man the Hunter symposium in 1966 (Hiatt 1968) by telling Levi-Strauss that Gidjingali women, and by implication many other Aboriginal women, were not exchanged between patrilineal clans, but were bestowed by individuals outside their own clan, namely their mothers and mother's brothers. After the symposium the editors of the Man the Hunter volume invited Levi-Strauss to comment on Hiatt's work, which he did dismissing it on the grounds of the recency of his fieldwork (1958-1960), which meant that he was dealing with 'what is left of a collapsing tribe' (1968:210-211). These fighting words are a good measure of the significance the debate had at that time. Joseph Birdsell provided his own version of Levi-Strauss's argument in 1970, in what was the last defensive sally in this debate.
- I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. Críticas de Libro (2024)
- I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. Comentarios del libro
- I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. Libros Similares
Nombre del libro | I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. |
Género | Ciencias sociales |
Autor | Oceania |
Publicado | miércoles, 1 de marzo de 2006 |
Idioma | Español |
Tamaño del e-libro | 209.31 KB |
I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. (Oceania) Análisis y Personajes
¡Disfrute de transferencias máximas altas en más de 20 monedas mientras ahorra hasta un 90% en los bancos locales! La forma rápida y barata de enviar dinero al extranjero. ¡Transferencia gratuita hasta 500 Euro!
¿Sabías que puedes ganar 25 USD en nuestro sitio con solo registrarte? ¡Obtenga $25 gratis uniéndose a Payoneer!
¡Por favor espera! I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. cargando comentarios del libro...
Comentario de I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde., libro de Oceania
¿Ya leíste este libro? ¿Qué opinas del libro I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. de Oceania? ¡Haga una pregunta a la comunidad de bookpedia.co sobre I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde.!
I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. Libros Similares
Nombre del libro | Calificar | Reseñas | Precio |
En busca de consuelo | 0/5 | 0 | 9,99 € |
Liderazgo. El poder de la inteligencia emocional | 4/5 | 7 | 7,99 € |
Convivir | 0/5 | 0 | 7,49 € |
Ultralearning | 0/5 | 0 | 10,99 € |
Arden las redes | 5/5 | 7 | 5,99 € |
Descarga de I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. E-Book
El libro I can't Follow You on This Horde-Clan Business at All': Donald Thomson, Radcliffe-Brown and a Final Note on the Horde. escrito por Oceania se publicó el miércoles, 1 de marzo de 2006 en la categoría Ciencias sociales. Un total de 110 lectores del libro le dieron al libro 0 puntos sobre 5. Se actualizará el enlace de descarga del libro electrónico i can't follow you on this horde-clan business at all': donald thomson, radcliffe-brown and a final note on the horde. (209.31 KB)
Nombre del libro | Calificar | Reseñas | Precio |
Searching for the Intercultural, Searching for the Culture. | 0/5 | 0 | 2,99 € |
Western Arrernte Pmere Kwetethe Spirits. | 0/5 | 0 | 2,99 € |
Valleys of Historicity and Ways of Power Among the Fuyuge. | 0/5 | 0 | 2,99 € |
The Brief Reach of History and the Limitation of Recall in Traditional Aboriginal Societies and Cultures. | 0/5 | 0 | 2,99 € |
Mejore el sueño, la visión, la cognición, la flexibilidad, la energía, la salud a largo plazo y más. Las fórmulas CORE de Performance Lab respaldan todos los aspectos del rendimiento humano, en todos los ámbitos de la vida. Aumenta el rendimiento laboral y la productividad con nootrópicos para concentrarse, realizar múltiples tareas bajo estrés, resolución creativa de problemas y más.
Nombre del libro | Autor | Precio |
Vindication of the Rights of Woman | Mary Wollstonecraft | Free |
Redes sociales en la adolescencia | Pilar Lacasa, de la Fuente, Julián & Méndez, Laura | Free |
Despejando la senda de la igualdad | Anastasia Téllez Infantes | Free |
Criminal Sociology | Enrico Ferri | Free |
The Positive School of Criminology | Enrico Ferri | Free |
Coinbase es el lugar más fiable del mundo para comprar y vender criptodivisas. Abre una cuenta hoy mismo y, si compras o vendes 100 $ o más en criptodivisas, ¡recibirás 10 $ de Bitcoin gratis!
Nombre del libro | Autor | Precio |
El arte de la guerra | Sun Tzu | $3.99 |
Un mundo al alcance de la mano | Javier Albiñana Serraín & Maylis de Kerangal | $9.99 |
Diccionario de las cosas que no supe explicarte | Risto Mejide | $6.99 |
Comemos lo que somos | J.M. Mulet | $10.99 |
Madre patria | Marcelo Gullo Omodeo | $9.99 |
Jasper es la plataforma de inteligencia artificial generativa para empresas que ayuda a su equipo a crear contenido personalizado para su marca 10 veces más rápido, dondequiera que trabaje en línea.