Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. Book Reviews
Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. by Supreme Court of New York Book Summary
[51 A.D.2d 668 Page 668] Judgment unanimously affirmed, without costs and without prejudice, in accordance with the following memorandum: We affirm the dismissal of this article 78 proceeding but on a ground different from that stated at Special Term. Special Term dismissed petitioner's article 78 proceeding in which he sought to recover money damages primarily for lost wages as a result of an unlawful discharge as a civil service employee, holding that an article 78 proceeding was not the proper form in which to pursue the recovery of monetary damages when the right to reinstatement had already been judicially determined in a prior article 78 proceeding. We cannot agree. An article 78 proceeding should not be dismissed solely because of petitioner's error in choosing between the form of a special proceeding and an action at law (Matter of Lakeland Water Dist. v Onondaga County Water Auth., 24 N.Y.2d 400; Phalen v Theatrical Protective Union No. 1, 22 N.Y.2d 34). Once a court has obtained jurisdiction over all of the parties, a civil judicial proceeding should not be dismissed solely because it was not brought in the proper form, but the court should make whatever order is required for its proper prosecution (CPLR 103, subd [c]). In view of the fact that there was no claim that the court lacked personal jurisdiction over the parties, it had the power to convert this special proceeding into an action at law. This claim for monetary damages against respondent New York State Civil Service Commission, however, may not be pursued in Supreme Court, but must be pursued in the Court of Claims (Court of Claims Act, § 9, subd 4; see, 8 Weinstein-Korn-Miller, NY Civ Prac, par 7806.01). Regardless of its undoubted power to convert, Special Term lacked subject matter jurisdiction in this article 78 proceeding and, therefore, the petition must be dismissed. The fact that petitioner first established in a prior article 78 proceeding his right to reinstatement to his full civil service status without seeking damages in that proceeding does not serve now to bar him from seeking damages. CPLR 7806 provides that damages granted to the petitioner must be incidental to the primary relief sought by the petitioner. This statutory language limits the recovery of damages in a special proceeding to those damages demanded in the proceeding in which the primary relief is simultaneously sought. This language should not be construed, however, as compelling a waiver of damages should petitioner elect not to establish them along with his right to primary relief in an article 78 proceeding (see Toscano v McGoldrick, 300 NY 156). Once petitioner established that he had been unlawfully removed from his job and procured a court order, affirmed by [51 A.D.2d 668 Page 669]
Book Name | Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. |
Genre | Law |
Author | Supreme Court of New York |
Published | 16 January 1976, Friday |
Language | English |
E-Book Size | 73.78 KB |
Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. (Supreme Court of New York) Book Reviews 2024
We transfer money over €4 billion every month. We enable individual and business accounts to save 4 million Euros on bank transfer fees. Want to send free money abroad or transfer money abroad for free? Free international money transfer!
Did you know that you can earn 25 USD from our site just by registering? Get $25 for free by joining Payoneer!
Download Link | Book Format |
matter-richard-j-adams-v-new-york-state-ebook.pdf | |
matter-richard-j-adams-v-new-york-state-ebook.epub | EPUB |
matter-richard-j-adams-v-new-york-state-ebook.kindle | KINDLE |
Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. E-book (PDF, PUB, KINDLE) Download
Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. ebook matter-richard-j-adams-v-new-york-state (73.78 KB) download new links will be update!
Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. Similar Books
Book Name | Score | Reviews | Price |
Notorious RBG | 4.5/5 | 240 | $18.99 |
Trouble in Mudbug | 4.5/5 | 2,699 | Free |
Law | 0/5 | 0 | Free |
The Litigators | 4/5 | 6,507 | $9.99 |
The New Jim Crow | 4/5 | 358 | $9.99 |
Enhance sleep, vision, cognition, flexibility, energy, long-range health and more. Performance Lab CORE Formulas support all aspects of human performance, across all walks of life. Boosts work performance and productivity with nootropics for focus, multitasking under stress, creative problem-solving and more.
Book Name | Score | Reviews | Price |
Angelo Pioli v. Morgan Guaranty Trust Company New York | 0/5 | 0 | $0.99 |
People State New York v. Ronald J. Trucchio | 0/5 | 0 | $0.99 |
Banco Espanol De Credito v. Pierre S. Du Pont | 0/5 | 0 | $0.99 |
People State New York v. Dominick Cappolla | 0/5 | 0 | $0.99 |
Great Neck Car Care Center v. Artpat Auto Repair Corp. | 0/5 | 0 | $0.99 |
Summary of Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. by Supreme Court of New York
The Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. book written by Supreme Court of New York was published on 16 January 1976, Friday in the Law category. A total of 44 readers of the book gave the book 0 points out of 5.
Book Name | Author | Price |
The Future of International Law | Lassa Oppenheim | Free |
The Common Law | Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. | Free |
Common Mistakes Gun Owners Make | Attorney James "Mitch" Vilos | Free |
International Law | Manfred Küng | Free |
The Little Green Book of Real Estate | Walker Morris | Free |
Coinbase is the world's most trusted place to buy and sell cryptocurrency. Open an account today, and if you buy or sell $100 or more of crypto, you'll receive $10 worth of free Bitcoin!
Book Name | Author | Price |
The Harm in Hate Speech | Jeremy Waldron | $23.99 |
The Rights of Indians and Tribes | Stephen L. Pevar | $24.99 |
Leyes y leyendas | Víctor Daniel Cabezas | $10.99 |
The Oath | Jeffrey Toobin | $5.99 |
One L | Scott Turow | $11.99 |
Jasper is the generative AI platform for business that helps your team create content tailored for your brand 10X faster, wherever you work online.
Please wait! Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. book comments loading...
Supreme Court of New York - Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. Discussions & Comments
Have you read this book yet? What do you think about Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al. by Supreme Court of New York book? Ask the bookpedia.co community a question about Matter Richard J. Adams v. New York State Civil Service Commission Et Al.!